Through the Looking-Glass: Investment Transparency of Canadian Foundations
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.29173/cjnser780Keywords:
transparency, philanthropic foundations, financial reporting, nonprofit governance, investment practicesAbstract
Foundations are under increased scrutiny as to the source, investment, and use of their assets. Although disclosure of total assets and disbursements is mandatory in many countries, information on investment portfolios is not required and, historically, foundations have rarely volunteered suchninformation. However, the rise of trust-based philanthropy and interest in impact and responsible investing encourage greater voluntary investment transparency. This article examines the current state of investment transparency among Canadian foundations, which collectively hold over $135 billion in long-term investment portfolios. Through interviews with foundation leaders, it explores the perceived benefits and barriers to investment transparency, and the factors that support or inhibit greater openness. While the findings indicate that Canadian foundations value transparency in general, voluntary disclosure on investments is limited due to a variety of risk factors and the lack of demand from stakeholders or the public. The study also points to emerging trends that are raising expectations for greater investment transparency by foundations.
Downloads
References
Barr, C. and Lasby, D. (2012). Transparency among Canadian charities. The Philanthropist 24(3): 223--226.
Boston College. (2008). Handbook on responsible investment across asset classes. Boston: Center for Corporate Citizenship. https://iri.hks.harvard.edu/files/iri/files/iri_handbook_on_responsible_investment_across_asset_classes.pdf
Bovens, M. (2010). Two concepts of accountability: Accountability as a virtue and as a mechanism. West European Politics 33(5): 946--967.
Brody, E. and Tyler, J. (2010). Respecting foundation and charity autonomy: How public is
private philanthropy. Chicago--Kent Law Review 85: 571--617.
Brouard, F., ad Pilon, M. (2020). Financial accountability and reporting of foundations in Canada. In P. R. Elson, S. A. Lefèvre and J.--M. Fontan (eds.), Philanthropic Foundations in Canada– Landscapes, Indigenous Perspectives and Pathways to Change (54–82). Montreal: Alliance Publishing Trust.
Buteau, E., Glickman, J., Leiwant, M. and Loh, C. (2016). Sharing what matters: Foundation
transparency. Cambridge, MA: The Centre for Effective Philanthropy. https://cep.org/wp--content/uploads/2019/08/CEP_Sharing--What--Matters--Foundation--Transparency_2016.pdf
Canada Revenue Agency. (2024). Completing the registered charity information return. Ottawa, ON: Government of Canada.
Carter, T. S., Lazier, K. and Westerhof, L. (2023). Investment powers for charities in Canada. The Philanthropist. 28 February. https://thephilanthropist.ca/2023/02/investment--powers--for--charities--in--canada/
Collins, C., Flannery, H. and Hoxie, J. (2018). Warehousing wealth: Donor--advised charity funds sequestering billion in the face of growing inequality. Washington, DC: Institute for Policy Studies.
CommonFund Institute. (2019). Principles of investment stewardship for nonprofit
organizations. Wilton, CO: Common fund Institute. https://info.commonfund.org/investment--management--for--nonprofit--investors
Council on Foundation/Commonfund. (2022). Study of investment of endowments
for private and community foundations. Washington, DC: Council on Foundations/Commonfund. https://cof.org/content/2022--council--foundations--commonfund--study--investment--endowments--private--and--community
Department of Finance (Canada). (2022). Budget 2022 – A plan to grow our economy and make life more affordable. Ottawa, ON: Government of Canada.
Dhami, N. (2021). Reflections on how we build a more equitable and transparent
financial future in Canada. Philanthropic Foundations of Canada. https://pfc.ca/reflections--on--how--we--build--a--more--equitable--and--transparent--financial--future--in--canada/
Elson, P. R., Glass, J. and Pole, N. (2022). Special feature: Shining light on transparency, openness
and accountability in foundations, reflections and tools. The Philanthropic Year Fall 2022. Montreal: PhiLab. https://philab.uqam.ca/wp--content/uploads/2022/11/LAnnee--PhiLanthropique--The--PhiLanthropic--Year.pdf
Fleishman, J. L. (2007). The foundation: A great American secret; how private wealth is
changing the world. New York: Public Affairs.
Fox, J. (2007). The uncertain relationship between transparency and accountability. Development in Practice 17 (4–5): 663–71.
Fugiel Gartner, M. (2024). An evolving landscape: Reflecting Canada’s philanthropic foundations. Montreal: Philanthropic Foundations Canada. https://pfc.ca/wp--content/uploads/2024/04/Executive--Summary--2024--Landscape--Report--V2.pdf
GIIN – Global Impact Investing Network. (2017). Core characteristics of impact investing. https://thegiin.org/publication/post/core--characteristics--of--impact--investing/
Holder, S., Lu, T., Sugiura, A., Beck, J., & Press, J. (2024). Endowment funds are not going
to disclose and divest. Bloomberg. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2024--04--27/college--protests--university--endowments--won--t--disclose--and--divest--podcast?embedded--checkout=true
Imagine Canada. (2022). Standards gap analysis tool. Toronto: Imagine Canada. https://imaginecanada.ca/en/standards/gap--analysis--tool
Johnson Center. (2023). 11 Trends for philanthropy in 2023. Grand Rapids, MI: Dorothy A. Johnson Center for Philanthropy, Grand Valley State University. 11--Trends--for--2023--Report.pdf
Justice Fund. (2021). Justice fund calls on Canadian government to #movethemoney from foundations currently hoarding over $85 billion. https://www.newswire.ca/news--releases/justice--fund--calls--on--canadian--government--to--movethemoney--from--foundations--currently--hoarding--over--85--billion--816481634.html
Mahlab, S. and Harrison, B. (2016). Effective and emerging approaches to mission--related
investing. Washington, DC: Council on Foundations.
Millani Investments. (2021). Investment & disbursement survey executive summary. Montreal: Philanthropic Foundations Canada. https://pfc.ca/documents/investment--disbursement--survey--executive--summary--2018--2020/
MPNL Philanthrothink. (2023). Wise investment: ESG, impact and responsible investing. PANL Perspectives. https://carleton.ca/mpnl/2023/wise--investment--esg--impact--responsible--investing--a--philanthrothink--mpnl--webinar--may--11/
Northcott, A. (2022). Governments shouldn’t push endowments into responsible investing. The
Philanthropist. 19 September. https://thephilanthropist.ca/2022/09/governments--shouldnt--push--endowments--into--responsible--investing/
Omidvar, R. (2023). Bill S – 279, Registered Charity Board Diversity Data Collection Act. Ottawa: Government of Canada. https://www.parl.ca/DocumentViewer/en/44--1/bill/S--279/first--reading.
OECD. (2003). Public sector transparency and the international investor. Paris: OECD.
https://www.oecd.org/investment/investment--policy/18546790.pdf
PAGVS – Panel on Accountability and Governance in the Voluntary Sector. (1999). Building on strength: Improving governance and accountability in Canada’s voluntary sector. Toronto and Ottawa: PAGVS.
Phillips, S. D. (2013). Shining light on charities or looking in the wrong place? Transparency and co--regulation in Canada. Voluntas 24 (3): 881--905.
Pilon, M. and Brouard, F. (2023). Conceptualizing accountability as an integrated system of relationships, governance, and information. Financial Accountability & Management 39: 421–446.
Reich, R. (2018) Just giving: Why philanthropy is failing democracy and how it can do better. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Sarasin & Partners. (2020). Compendium of investment. London, UK: Sarasin & Partners.
https://sarasinandpartners.com/compendium/#storeindividual
Saxton, G. D., Kuo, J.--S. and Ho, Y.--C. (2012). The determinants of voluntary financial disclosure by nonprofit organizations. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 41 (6): 1051–71.
Schorr, L. B. (2004). From knowledge management to knowledge building: An essential foundation journey’. New Directions for Philanthropic Fundraising (45): 51–61.
Sjögren, K. (2024). The asset manager tango. PANL Perspectives. 23 October. https://carleton.ca/panl/2024/the--asset--manager--tango/
Veritas Foundation. (2024). Charity reviews. https://theveritasfoundation.com/charityreviews
WINGS. (2015). Toolkit: Transparency and accountability in philanthropy and private social
investment. Issue Lab. https://wings.issuelab.org/resources/20911/20911.pdf
Wood, D. (2020). Roles foundations play in shaping impact investing. Stanford Social Innovation Review. 13 July. https://ssir.org/articles/entry/roles_foundations_play_in_shaping_impact_investing#
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Melissa Wilson, Susan D. Phillips
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Submission of an original manuscript to the Canadian Journal of Nonprofit and Social Economy Research / Revue canadienne de recherche sur les OSBL et l'économie sociale [thereafter CJNSER] will be taken to mean that it represents original work not previously published, and that it is not being considered elsewhere for publication.
The journal takes the stance that the publication of scholarly research is meant to disseminate knowledge and, in a not-for-profit regime, benefits neither publisher nor author financially. It sees itself as having an obligation to its authors and to society to make content available online now that the technology allows for such a possibility. In keeping with this principle, the journal will publish all of its issues online.
Authors who publish in CJNSER agree to release their articles under the Creative Commons 4.0 International Licence (CC BY). This licence allows anyone to copy and distribute the article provided that appropriate attribution is given. For details of the rights an author grants users of their work, please see the licence summary and the full licence.
[Content published between 2010 and 2019-10 was licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 Canada (CC BY-NC-ND 2.5 CA) License. Content published between 2019-10 to 2023-12 was licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) License. Content published after 2023-12 is licensed under the Creative Commons 4.0 International (CC BY) License.]
