Analyzing Recent Citizen Participation Trends in Western New York: Comparing Citizen Engagement Promoted by Local Governments and Nonprofit Organizations

Jyldyz Kasymova


Engaging citizens in the decision-making process is becoming an important priority for many local governments. This article evaluates three citizen engagement events in two jurisdictions in western New York: public forums held by the Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority, Citizen Participation Academy, and Participatory Budgeting Project. Using in-depth interviews with public and nonprofit employees, the article outlines several findings, including a distinctly higher level of effectiveness of engagement strategies when advanced by not-for-profit organizations. The engagement initiated by state and municipal governments reflects authoritarian and bureaucratic models of participation. This study highlights several challenges to the sustainability of citizen involvement at municipal levels, and its results have important implications for other towns implementing participatory tools.


Pour plusieurs gouvernements locaux, l’engagement des citoyens dans la prise de décision devient prioritaire. Cet article examine cette situation en évaluant trois événements portant sur l’engagement des citoyens dans deux juridictions de l’ouest de l’État du New York, à savoir des forums publics organisés par le Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority, le Citizen Participation Academy et le Participatory Budgeting Project. Au moyen d’entrevues en profondeur auprès d’employés des secteurs public et sans but lucratif, cet article fait plusieurs constats, y compris celui d’une efficacité beaucoup plus grande des stratégies d’engagement suivies par les organisations sans but lucratif. En revanche, l’engagement sollicité par les gouvernements des États et des municipalités reflète des modèles de participation relativement autoritaires et bureaucratiques. Cette étude souligne plusieurs défis soulevés au niveau municipal par les tentatives d’inclure la citoyenneté. Les résultats de cette étude ont des implications importantes pour d’autres villes qui s’efforcent d’encourager la participation.


Citizen participation; Local government; Nonprofit; Participatory budgeting / Participation citoyenne; Gouvernement local; Sans but lucratif; Établissement de budget participatif

Full Text:



Adams, B. 2004. Public Meetings and the Democratic Process. Public Administration Review, 64: 43–54. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-6210.2004.00345.x

Arnstein, S.R. 1969. Eight Rungs on the Ladder of Citizen Participation. In B. Kahn and E. Passett (Eds.). Citizen Participation: Effecting Community Change. New York: Praeger.

Bagley, Jessica. 2013. Looking to the future. Tonawanda News. Available on June 18, 2014, Retrieved at

Barnes, M., Newman, J. & Sullivan, H. 2007. Power, Participation, and Political Renewal. Bristol: The Policy Press.

Berner, M. 2001. Citizen Participation in Local Government Budgeting. Popular Government, 66 (3): 23–30.

Berner, M., & Smith, S. 2004. The state of the states: A review of state requirements for citizen participation in the local government budgeting process. State and Local Government Review, 36(2): 140–150.

Berry, J. M., Portney, K. E., Bablitch, M. B., & Mahoney, R. 1984. Public involvement in administration: The structural determinants of effective citizen participation. Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 13(2), 7-23

Box, R. C. 1998. Citizen governance: Leading American communities into the 21st century. Sage: Thousand Oaks.

Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority. 2003. Review of Four Year Financial Plan. Available on May 9, 2014. Retrieved at

Carr, D. S., & Halvorsen, K. 2001. An evaluation of three democratic, community-based approaches to citizen participation: Surveys, conversations with community groups, and community dinners. Society & Natural Resources, 14(2): 107-126

Cortner HJ, Moote MA.1999. The Politics of Ecosystem Management. Washington, DC: Island Press

Dillaway, D. 2006. Power Failure: Politics, Patronage, and the Economic Future of Buffalo. New York. Amherst, N.Y: Prometheus Books.

Dalehite, E. G. 2008. Determinants of Performance Measurement: An Investigation into the Decision to Conduct Citizen Surveys. Public Administration Review, 68: 891–907. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-6210.2008.00930.x

Ebdon, C. 2000. The Relationship between Citizen Involvement in the Budget Process and Town Structure and Culture. Public Productivity & Management Review, 23(3): 383–393.

Ebdon, C., & Franklin, A. 2004. Searching for a Role for Citizens in the Budget Process. Public Budgeting and Finance, 24(1): 32–49.

Ebdon, C., & Franklin, A. 2006. Citizen Participation in Budgeting Theory. Public Administration Review, 66 (3): 437–447.

Folscher, A. 2007. Central and Eastern Europe. In Participatory Budgeting. Public Sector Governance and Accountability Series. Ed, Shah, A. Washington, DC: World Bank

Franklin, A. L., Ho, A. T., & Ebdon, C. 2009. Participatory Budgeting in Midwestern States: Democratic Connection or Citizen Disconnection. Public Budgeting and Finance, 29(3): 52–73.

Franklin, A., & Ebdon, C. 2005. Are We All Touching the Same Camel? Exploring a Model of Participation in Budgeting. American Review of Public Administration, 35(2): 168–185.

Gao, J. 2012. How Does Chinese Local Government Responds to Citizen Satisfaction Surveys? A Case Study of Foshan City. The Australian Journal of Public Administration. 71(2): 136-147.

Goldfrank, B. & Schneider, A. 2006. Competitive Institution Building: The PT and Participatory Budgeting in Rio Grande do Sul. Latin American Politics and Society 48: 1–31. doi: 10.1111/j.1548-2456.2006.tb00354.x

Goetz, A.M. & Gaventa, J. 2001. Bringing Citizen Voice and Client Focus into Service Delivery. IDS Working Paper 138, Brighton: IDS

Hassett, W. & Watson, D. 2003. Citizen Surveys: a Component of the Budgetary Process. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting and Financial Management, 15(4): 525-541

Hochsztein, J. 2011. Citizens Academies: A Tool for Increasing Civic Engagement. Masters Theses. The University of North Carolina.

Im, T. & Lee S. J. 2011. Does Management Performance Impact Citizen Satisfaction. American Review of Public Administration. 42(4): 419-436.

Institute for Local Governance and Regional Growth. 2003. Report to the Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority on Public Comments Pertaining to The City Of Buffalo’s Four-Year Financial Plan. Buffalo: University of Buffalo. Retrieved at (Available December 30, 2013).

Kasymova, J. T., & Schachter, H. L. 2014. Bringing Participatory Tools to a Different Level. Public Performance & Management Review, 37(3): 441-464

King, C., Feltey, K. M., & Susel, B. O. 1998. The Question of Participation: Toward Authentic Public Participation in Public Administration. Public Administration Review, 58(4): 317–326.

Kuo, N.-L. 2012. Citizen Dissatisfaction Leads to Budget Cuts, or Not: A Case Study of a Local Taiwanese Government. Australian Journal of Public Administration, (71): 159–166. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-8500.2012.00762.x

Koontz T.M., Steelman T.A., Carmin J., Korfmacher K.S., Moseley C., & Thomas C.W. 2004. Collaborative Environmental management what: roles for government? Resources for the Future Press. Washington, DC: RFF Press

Leighninger, M. 2014. Want to Increase Trust in Government? Update Our Public Participation Laws. Public Administration Review, 74: 305–306. doi: 10.1111/puar.12208

Li, Wanxin, Jieyan Liu, & Duoduo Li. 2012. Getting their voices heard: Three cases of public participation in environmental protection in China. Journal of Environmental Management, 98: 65-72

Mancuso, S. 2009. Buffalo Fiscal Stability Authority. Buffalo: Partnership for Public Goods. Available on June 18, 2014. Retrieved at

Marcus, A. S. 2007. Local Government Citizen Academies: is Knowledge Power? Thesis. Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Miller, T. & Miller, M. 1991. Citizen Surveys: How to Do Them, How to Use Them, What They Mean. Washington, DC: International City/County Management Association.

Morse, R. S. 2012. Citizens Academies: Local Governments Building Capacity for Citizen Engagement. Public Performance & Management Review, 36 (1) (September): 79-101

New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. 2009. Tonawanda Community Air Quality Study. Available on June 18, 2014. Retrieved at

Orosz, J. F. 2002. Views from the Field: Creating a Place for Authentic Citizen in Budgeting. Journal of Public Budgeting, Accounting & Financial Management, 14(3): 423–442.

Paul, S. 2007. Civic Participation in Subnational Budgeting. In Shah, A. Participatory Budgeting. Washington: DC, World Bank

Poister, T. H. & Thomas, J. C. 2007. The Wisdom of Crowds: Learning from Administrators’ Predictions of Citizen Perceptions. Public Administration Review, 67: 279–289. doi: 10.1111/j.1540-6210.2007.00713.x

Rivenbark, W. C., & Ballard, E. C. 2012. Using Citizen Surveys to Influence and Document Culture Change in Local Government. Public Performance & Management Review, 35(3): 475-484.

Schachter, H. L. 1997. Reinventing government or reinventing ourselves: The role of citizen owners in making a better government. Albany: State University of New York Press

Schneider, A. & Ingram, H. 1997. Policy Design for Democracy. Lawrence: University Press of Kansas.

Silverman, R., Taylor, H. & Crawford, C. 2008. The Role of Citizen Participation and Action Research Principles in Main Street Revitalization: An Analysis of a Local Planning Project. Action Research 6 (1): 69-93.

Simonsen, W. & Robbins, M.D. 2000. Citizen Participation in Resource Allocation. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Swindell, D. & Kelly, J. 2000.Linking Citizen Satisfaction Data to Performance Measures. Public Performance & Management Review, 24 (1) (September): 30-52.

Soss, J.1999. Lessons of Welfare: Policy Design, Political Learning, and Political Action. American Political Science Review, 93 (June): 363-380.

Van Ryzin, G. & Charbonneau, É. 2010. Public Service Use and Perceived Performance: an Empirical Note on the Nature of The Relationship. Public Administration, 88: 551–563. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9299.2010.01820.x

Verschelde , M. & Rogge, N. 2012.An Environment-adjusted Evaluation of Citizen Satisfaction with Local Police Effectiveness: Evidence from a Conditional Data Envelopment Analysis Approach. European Journal of Operational Research. 223 (1) (November): 214–225

Waheduzzaman and Mphande, C. H. 2014. Gaps in Pursuing Participatory Good Governance Bangladesh Context. Administration & Society, 46(1): 37-69.

Watson, D. J., Juster, R. J., & Johnson, G. W. 1991. Institutionalized Use of Citizen Surveys in the Budgetary and Policy-making Processes: A Small Town Case Study. Public Administration Review, 51(3): 232–239.

Wondolleck J.M. & Yaffee S.L. 2000. Making Collaboration Work: Lessons from Innovation in Natural Resource Management. Washington, DC: Island Press

World Bank. 2012. What is Demand for Good Governance. Retrieved online.,,contentMDK:22675075~menuPK:7430607~pagePK:210058~piPK:210062~theSitePK:3035864,00.html

Yang, K. & Callahan, K. 2007. Citizen Involvement Efforts and Bureaucratic Responsiveness: Participatory Values, Stakeholder Pressures, and Administrative Practicality. Public Administration Review 67(2): 249-264.

Yin, R. 2009. Case Study Research. Design and Methods. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE.



  • There are currently no refbacks.